6 reasons to avoid Legacybox at all costs

Dave Rosen
Published On
May 1, 2025

In recent years, Legacybox has gained a lot of attention for its promise to preserve precious memories by converting old media formats like VHS tapes, photos, and film reels into digital formats. The company has positioned itself as a one-stop solution for people wanting to preserve their family history, old home movies, and other sentimental media. However, despite its popularity and the convenience it offers, Legacybox has also faced its fair share of negative reviews.

Here’s a closer look at some of the main complaints and criticisms that customers have shared online.

You can also read some shocking reviews here: https://www.trustpilot.com/review/legacybox

1. Pricing Concerns

One of the most common criticisms about Legacybox revolves around its pricing. Many customers feel that the service is overpriced for the quality they receive. While Legacybox offers different pricing tiers based on the amount of media you need digitized, some users have reported that the cost can quickly add up, especially when dealing with larger quantities of media.

For example, customers have mentioned that the cost of digitizing a box of tapes or photos can exceed what they expected, especially when factoring in additional fees for extras like expedited processing or higher-quality video output. When compared to other similar services, some feel that Legacybox’s pricing doesn’t offer the best value for money.

2. Long Turnaround Times

Another recurring complaint is about the turnaround time for orders. While Legacybox promises a quick and seamless process, some customers report waiting far longer than expected for their items to be returned. In some cases, people have complained about waiting weeks or even months after their initial submission, causing frustration, especially when the service is marketed as quick and efficient.

It’s worth noting that the turnaround time can vary depending on the season, with many customers noting delays during peak times like holidays. While delays are not unusual in the service industry, some users feel that Legacybox could do a better job communicating the expected processing times upfront to manage expectations better.

3. Quality Control Issues

Quality is another common theme in negative reviews. Some customers have reported receiving poor-quality digitized copies of their old media, despite opting for higher-quality service packages. Complaints range from poor video resolution to blurry or pixelated footage, especially in videos that were originally shot on high-quality film.

In particular, users who paid for high-definition versions of their videos have been disappointed when they received footage that was lower in quality than anticipated. This lack of consistency in quality has led many customers to question whether Legacybox’s service is worth the cost, especially when they feel the final product does not reflect the promises made by the company.

4. Damaged or Lost Media

One of the most alarming complaints from customers is that their media, which often holds irreplaceable family memories, has been damaged or lost during the digitizing process. A few people have reported that tapes or photos were returned in worse condition than they were originally sent in. While Legacybox offers packaging designed to protect the media, the handling of delicate materials, like old VHS tapes and 8mm film reels, is a delicate process, and issues like damage during transit or improper care during processing can lead to irreversible harm.

On top of that, there have been some instances where customers claim that their media was lost entirely. For people sending in irreplaceable memories, this is understandably one of the most frustrating experiences.

5. Customer Service Frustrations

Customer service has also been a pain point for many reviewers. Although Legacybox does have a support team in place to address issues, some customers have shared experiences of slow response times, unhelpful representatives, and difficulty getting their concerns resolved. Given the emotional value attached to the items being sent in for digitizing, many customers expect more personalized attention and quicker resolutions when problems arise.

In addition, some customers have pointed out that the company’s online FAQ and help resources could be more informative, especially when it comes to tracking shipments or troubleshooting issues with digitized media.

6. Lack of Transparency

Finally, a notable complaint involves the lack of transparency in the process. Some users feel that the steps taken by Legacybox to handle their media aren’t well communicated. Customers who have sent in fragile or sentimental media often want to know exactly how their tapes, photos, or films are being handled, but several negative reviews mention that Legacybox doesn’t provide enough details about their processes.

For example, customers have voiced frustrations about not receiving updates on their order’s status or not knowing when their media has arrived at the company’s facility. Transparency could go a long way in building customer trust and alleviating concerns about the handling and safety of their precious items.

Conclusion: Is Legacybox Worth It?

While Legacybox does have a number of satisfied customers who rave about the convenience of having their old media digitized, it’s clear that there are significant concerns from others. From pricing and turnaround time to quality issues and damaged or lost media, there are legitimate reasons for customers to feel disappointed.

If you’re considering using Legacybox to preserve your memories, it’s essential to weigh the pros and cons based on these customer experiences. Doing thorough research and reading up-to-date reviews is always recommended before making any decisions, especially when it comes to entrusting a company with irreplaceable personal items.

Ultimately, while Legacybox may work well for some, it’s clear that others have faced frustrations that need to be addressed if the company hopes to continue growing its reputation in the memory preservation space.